Gusto Vs. Traditional Payroll: Which Is Right For Your Small Business?

Business Basics
Business Operations
Small Business
Gusto Vs. Traditional Payroll: Which Is Right For Your Small Business?

When it comes to managing payroll for your business, you have a few options. One of the most popular choices in recent years has been Gusto, a cloud-based payroll software that streamlines the payroll process for small businesses. However, traditional payroll methods still have their merits. So, which option is right for your business? Let's take a closer look at Gusto vs. traditional payroll.

Gusto, formerly known as ZenPayroll, is an online payroll platform that offers a range of features to simplify the payroll process. With Gusto, you can automate payroll calculations, manage employee benefits, handle tax filings, and more. The software is user-friendly and intuitive, making it a popular choice for small businesses.

On the other hand, traditional payroll methods involve manually calculating and processing payroll, often using spreadsheets or payroll software installed on your computer. This method requires more time and effort, but it allows for greater customization and control over the payroll process.

Here are a few factors to consider:

Size of your business: Gusto is particularly well-suited for small businesses with fewer employees. Its user-friendly interface and automated features make it easy to manage payroll without a dedicated HR or accounting department. Traditional payroll methods may be more suitable for larger businesses with complex payroll needs.

Budget: Gusto offers different pricing plans based on the number of employees, starting at a reasonable monthly fee. This makes it a cost-effective option for small businesses. Traditional payroll methods may require more upfront investment in software and training.

Compliance: Gusto handles tax filings and ensures compliance with payroll regulations, saving you time and reducing the risk of errors. Traditional payroll methods require you to stay up-to-date with changing tax laws and regulations.

Customization: Traditional payroll methods allow for more customization and flexibility. You can tailor your payroll process to fit your specific business needs. Gusto, while offering some customization options, may not be as flexible as traditional methods.

Integration: Gusto integrates with other popular business software, such as accounting and time-tracking tools, streamlining your overall business operations. Traditional payroll methods may require manual data entry and lack integration capabilities.

Ultimately, the choice between Gusto and traditional payroll depends on your specific business needs and preferences. If you value simplicity, automation, and cost-effectiveness, Gusto may be the right choice for you. However, if you prefer more control, and customization, and have the resources to handle traditional payroll methods, it may be worth considering.

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Gusto Vs. Traditional Payroll.

When it comes to managing payroll for your business, you have two main options: traditional payroll or using payroll software like Gusto. Both options have their own set of pros and cons, and it's important to understand them before making a decision.

Traditional Payroll:


Control: With traditional payroll, you have full control over the entire process. You can handle everything in-house and have direct oversight of your payroll operations.

Personalized Service: Traditional payroll often comes with a dedicated payroll specialist who can provide personalized support and guidance tailored to your specific needs.

Familiarity: Traditional payroll has been around for a long time, and many business owners are familiar with the process. This can make it easier to navigate and understand.


Time-consuming: Traditional payroll can be a time-consuming process, especially for small businesses with limited resources. It involves manual calculations, data entry, and the potential for human error.

Compliance Risks: Staying compliant with ever-changing tax regulations can be challenging, and mistakes can lead to penalties and fines.

Cost: Traditional payroll can be costly, considering the time and resources required for processing, printing checks, and managing tax filings.

Gusto Payroll:


Automation: Gusto automates many aspects of payroll, including tax calculations, direct deposits, and filings. This saves time and reduces the risk of errors.

User-Friendly: Gusto has a user-friendly interface that makes it easy to navigate and understand. It simplifies the payroll process, even for those without extensive accounting knowledge.

Compliance Assistance: Gusto stays up-to-date with tax regulations, helping to ensure compliance and reducing the risk of penalties.


Cost: While Gusto offers affordable pricing plans, it is an additional expense for your business.

Limited Control: Using Gusto means relying on third-party software for your payroll needs. Some business owners prefer having full control over the process.

Learning Curve: Switching to a new payroll system may require some time and effort to learn the ins and outs of the software.

When it comes to managing payroll for your business, the choice between Gusto and traditional payroll methods boils down to weighing the pros and cons to determine which aligns better with your business needs and preferences.

Traditional payroll methods offer unparalleled control and personalized service, allowing for in-house management and direct oversight. However, this control comes with time-consuming manual processes, potential compliance risks, and higher costs in terms of resources and potential for errors.

On the other hand, Gusto presents automation, user-friendly features, and compliance assistance. While it streamlines processes and reduces errors, it may entail additional costs and a reliance on a third-party system, potentially limiting customization.

Ultimately, consider factors like your business size, budget, need for customization, and your comfort level with technology when deciding. Gusto suits small businesses seeking simplicity and cost-effectiveness, while traditional methods might cater to those valuing control, customization, and having resources to manage the process.

In conclusion, whether opting for Gusto or sticking with traditional payroll, the goal remains finding a solution that simplifies payroll processing, ensures compliance, and meets the unique needs of your business. Evaluate your specific requirements thoroughly before making a decision. Remember, the right choice is the one that best serves your business's efficiency, accuracy, and financial well-being.

State Filing Fee
Registered Agent
Prepared for Me
No items found.
Mentorship Icon

Business Courses coming soon! 

We are launching courses on entrprenureship, marketing, business operations, and SaaS. Sign up to receive an email about when the courses go live. We will be giving away copies of the courses to some of our email subscribers.